The children’s needs must come first
Yesterday, we were treated to a very common logical fallacy - the ad hominem argument, which is an argument made personally against an opponent instead of against their argument. So when Doug attacked Michelle Rhee's reputation yesterday, instead of addressing her claims, his comments were irrelevant to the argument. Furthermore, the ad hominem argument implies that if Rhee's claims had been made by, say, Mother Theresa or Al Gore, then they would have been acceptable and correct.
Interestingly, Rhee reveals in her book that she is a lifelong Democrat and had a hard time accepting the need for school vouchers when she became the school chancellor in Washington, DC. Her mind was changed, however, when she met with families who had no choice but to send their kids to a bad neighbourhood school. In her book (pp 250-251), Rhee writes: "I just couldn't look mother after mother in the eye and deny their children the opportunity I wanted for my own children. It would have required me to say, 'Gee, I'm sorry, you're just going to have to suck it up. I know your elementary school is a failing school, and your child will probably not learn how to read, but I really need five more years to fix the system. And while I'm fixing the system, I need you and your neighbors to be really patient. Hang in there with me. Things will get better, I promise.'
"If someone said that to me, I'd have said, 'You may need more time to fix the system but my kid doesn't have time. She has only one chance to attend first grade, and if she can't learn to read by the end of first grade, her chances for success in life will be compromised. So with all due respect - heck, no!'
"After my listening tour of families, and hearing so many parents plead for an immediate solution to their desire for a quality education, I came out in favor of the voucher program....
"Here's the question we Democrats need to ask ourselves: Are we beholden to the public school system at any cost, or are we beholden to the public school child at any cost? My loyalty and my duty will always be to the children."




Share this article