Donate now

Privacy Policy

Protection of privacy is our first concern, and SQE does not sell or trade information provided by its subscribers or supporters. Your information is used to process donations and newsletter subscriptions, and to contact you about upcoming publications and events.

feed iconRSS Feed

Follow Us
Follow SQESocQualEd
on Twitter

Please note Downloads require you to have the Adobe Reader installed, you can get it here for free Adobe.com

 

 
 
Society for Quality Education

Subscribe to our mailing list

Empowering Students

September 21, 2013 by .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) at 08:12 AM

GUEST BLOG BY TOM BEREND, SQE DIRECTOR

Somewhere in Ontario, a school board that doesn't yet want to be named is taking baby steps towards adopting Empower Reading. Huge kudos to Pamela Cairncross, an awesome, relentless parent who has been pushing hard on this for years.

Empower Reading is based on the research of Dr Maureen Lovett and her team of researchers at Sick Kids Hospital in Toronto. It is a comprehensive toolbox of research-based strategies and training materials focusing on accurate word recognition using phonological skills, synthetic phonics, and morphology. Empower stands in sharp contrast to whole-language programs such as Reading Recovery that encourage guessing at words from context. 

Five years ago, Pamela realized that her son was struggling with reading in grade 1. Her son's school told her not to worry and provided him with the usual accommodations, but it was clear that his teachers were not trained on reading disabilities and he would not get any actual help in learning to read.  Pamela started looking around.

Through the International Dyslexia Association Ontario Branch (ONBIDA), Pamela learned about systematic approaches to reading instruction. She worked on phonics with her son at home, and helped him master reading. And then she attended a presentation by Maureen Lovett at Queen's University in early 2012, and heard about Empower Reading. It was a relevation.

Empower was like her home program, but for a whole classroom including training for the teachers.  She contacted the principal of the local high school, and urged her to offer the program. This is not an appeal that school principals are typically receptive to, but Pamela was relentless. She and her husband even offered to help pay for it. The principal investigated the program, and courageously took the plunge to put in a pilot program for grades 9-12. It was a huge success, and so it is being rolled into grades 7-8 starting next week

But Pamela wasn't finished yet. Next she went after the school board. Pamela met with trustees, bombarded everyone she could find with information and testimonials, made presentations, and wrote letters. The board had already been talking to Sick Kids. Pamela, with the support of the principal, increased the pressure and momentum.

And so now this school board is making plans to start rolling out Empower Reading this year, perhaps eventually going board-wide. It is a major undertaking, a huge investment in the students, and so clearly the right thing to do. We'd love to applaud them publicly, but they are still working through the details and asked us not to.

Perhaps the trustees would have done this eventually anyhow. However, we like to think that a determined and single-minded parent can move mountains.

Share this article

Comments

Tom,I`d like to mention that Remediation Plus Systems is every bit as powerful as Empower Reading.I would actually add that it is superior in many ways and has had the blessing of Dr.Reid Lyon as well as Bob Sweet,the person involved in N.C.L.B.

The program is in the hands of 150 trained teachers,adding 20 this year at the District School Board of Niagara .We offer the true alternative to Reading Recovery and are known to compete perfectly with Empower.

If you wish to know,we have had two sales throughout school boards due to parent advocacy.

I`m sorry but promoting programs should not be allowed on this blog.

If you are going to do one then you must do the other!


http://www.remediationplus.com

Posted by Jo-Anne Gross on 09/21 at 08:42 AM

Kudos to the board and principal, and especially the mother for doing the right thing, but won’t the teachers’ unions object?  If not, why hasn’t proper reading instruction been introduced years and years ago?  I find this confounding.  Can anyone explain?

Posted by Bev on 09/21 at 10:45 AM

Hi Jo-Anne,

I intended this posting as a report on the activities of a tireless parent.  It wasn’t meant as a promotion for Empower Reading.

Your commitment to helping students with reading difficulties is unquestioned, and your excellent program is also based on accurate word recognition.

I’m sure there are other research-based programs available.  It hurts that many school boards use the expensive yet almost-worthless Reading Recovery program.  But that isn’t what this blog was about.

http://www.massey.ac.nz/massey/fms/Massey News/2013/8/docs/Report-National-Literacy-Strategy-2013.pdf

Posted by Tom on 09/21 at 10:55 AM

Hi,here is another by Dr. Bonnie Grossen at U of Oregon…

https://www.dys-add.com/resources/ReadingMethods/ReadingRecoveryUnivofORStudy.pdf

On another Linked In blog for Struggling Readers people are wondering who the decision makers are..indeed…

For every one of us who knows about the reading research there are 100,000 who know nothing and never came across it at University training institutes.

Posted by Jo-Anne Gross on 09/21 at 12:05 PM

I am inclined to agree with Joanne, however for different reasons. I have been following the Empower Reading program developed by the Toronto Sick Kids from the beginning. I must say, for all the press, why is the data of the reading outcomes cloaked in darkness? One would be hard press to find mentioned the Empower Reading program in the education/science journals.

At BEE -
Empower Reading (Reading)
Struggling Readers
Empower Reading has limited evidence of effectiveness for struggling readers. The two qualifying studies included in this review showed effect sizes of +0.71 and +0.25”  http://www.bestevidence.org/overviews/E/Empower-Reading.pdf

On the Empower web site - “Partnerships to transform struggling readers into capable readers and confident learners”  http://www.sickkids.ca/LDRP/Empower-Reading/Empower-reading-schools/index.html

The partnership between the education stakeholders and Sick Kids. Over at the Premier’s for Teachers’ Excellence - http://www.edu.gov.on.ca/teachingawards/bios2011.html  Scroll down near the bottom and under Life Time Achievement - the implications that the remedial reading programs across Canada are equal and no one remedial reading program is better than another for struggling readers. ” These evidence-based remedial programs, used across Canada and the United States, ensure successful readers, improved health and brighter futures.”

I beg to differ as a parent, but more importantly I want to stress what the Empower Reading Program is not. Its not a reading program that is designed to bring ALL students to average and above reading levels and to prevent reading struggles. That said, two news articles:
June, 2013 - “The Empower reading program is taught in all school in the AMDSB.”  http://www.mitchelladvocate.com/2013/06/19/empower-reading-program-having-great-success
September, 2013 - The unnamed school board in Tom’s blog -  http://www.easternontarionetwork.com/index.php/news/local-news/westportrideau/12252-rideau-s-grade-7-and-8s-benefit-from-new-reading-program

The question that goes unanswered - or as Tom’s post implies - The Empower Reading program - as describe in the first news link - “The program was designed to help students who have significant difficulty acquiring age-appropriate reading skills. The program, taught by special education resource teachers, takes small groups of students (six to eight) and gives them one-hour of instruction, four to five times a week, on reading skills. The students, in Grades 2 to 5, are given 110-hours of instruction total.”  What is the big secret, unless as cited by other school districts the costs are significantly higher concerning the Empower Reading program for so few students.

In closing, a single determined parent can moved mountains, but I bet Pamela Cairncross has her fair share of horror stories that are very similar to other parents across Canada. The horror stories of inappropriate and poor instructional programs for struggling students across Canada are not well publicized nor are the outcomes for the struggling students. In fact, across Canada a parent would be hard press to locate the names of the reading programs that are in use, the types, the funding dollars, the students that meet the criteria for access to the programs, and the reading outcomes of the students. Toss in the BLOB, how many students who are struggling in reading, are disqualified from entering the remediation reading programs like Empower because of the BLOB? 

It should be interesting reading, in the months to come because of the fallout dealing with the Moore court ruling. It appears that the Ontario school boards have taken a great interest in struggling readers based on the evidence in reports at the school board level since the beginning of 2013. Of course it has more to do with being slapped with a lawsuit than it does with actual concern of struggling readers.

Shouldn’t the school boards be discussing reading instructional programs such as Remediation Plus for the whole classroom, that will limit and prevent reading struggles in the higher grades???

Posted by Nancy on 09/21 at 12:51 PM

POBOD

No harm in experiments. We assume that school will rocket ahead now or people will drop the subject.

Posted by Malkin Dare on 09/21 at 02:27 PM

Leave A Comment

Be polite and respectful. Stay on-topic. State your position clearly and write succinctly. Provide support for claims. Don't hog the microphone. Strong opinions are OK, but outrage is not. Don't post just to upset others.

Name:

Email (required but not displayed):

Emotions

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Submit the word you see below: